This post is by faculty author Jill Darling
In the recent Digital Education Days panel, “Academic Integrity in the Era of AI,” Jennifer Fisch-Ferguson from Mott Community College spoke about generative AI pushing us to reflect on our pedagogical practices and course design. That, in the context of GenAI, we can see our assignments differently and adjust for student learning styles, confidence, stress, and time constraints. That all of this might, in fact, help us to engage with students more deeply. In the past few years, like so many others, I have come to see my teaching differently than I have in the past. It’s hard to admit out loud, but in a lot of ways GenAI–like ChatGPT, UMGPT and other large language models (LLMs)–has made me a better teacher, even though I don’t allow students to use it in my classes, not for any aspect of the coursework. I teach academic and creative writing courses, but there are many approaches to situating technology in teaching that don’t have to be discipline specific.
Since 2023, LLMs like ChatGPT have forced me to reevaluate what I was asking students to do in-person and online. Since then, I’ve spent a lot of time thinking, reading, and revising syllabi and assignments, and I’ve seen some positive pay off, even though trying to keep up with how fast these technologies are developing always feels impossible. Teaching writing over many years, I have always focused on process: brainstorming, generating ideas, drafting, giving and getting peer-reviewed feedback, and revising. In redesigning syllabi, I’ve thought even more about pulling that process apart and slowing it down to include more active and engaged reading, freewriting in response to texts from personal perspectives and experiences, reflecting on the benefits of developing strong critical and creative thinking skills, and more. I think that sometimes students take shortcuts when they don’t feel like agents in their own learning. Practicing the writing process–like training for a marathon or learning to play the piano–is just that, practice. And over time practice builds skill and muscle.
Many of my students already know a lot about ChatGPT and other programs and are pretty knowledgeable about what some of the problems are. Some students even refuse to use GenAI at all, which I think is an important perspective to recognize within the sea of AI tech band-wagoning in education that’s happening now. The Academic Integrity course policy I use asks students to do the work of writing, from brainstorming to revising, without AI-based tools, including Grammarly–which is AI-powered and may not help them learn to do on their own what it “fixes” automatically. In my own experience using Grammarly to understand how it works, and from conversations with students about their experiences, I’ve learned that beyond punctuation and low-level fixes, Grammarly tends to suggest more substantial revisions, from replacing vocabulary to rewriting whole sentences and paragraphs. I also stress why I have this policy:
**This is important because the writing process helps us all to practice thinking creatively and critically. For example: brainstorming, outlining, and drafting help us clarify thoughts and discover new questions and ideas; using library databases and thoughtful online searches help us learn how to find, examine, and incorporate credible and relevant sources (and recognize misinformation and non-credible sources); and reading and writing are important practices for synthesizing, analyzing, and reflecting on topics and issues in the world from our own informed, personal perspectives. Artificial Intelligence cannot do these kinds of thinking practices for us, which are crucially important as skills in the world, and more philosophically, for us as creative and critical humans sustaining the present and working toward a better future for everyone.
Further, I let students know that I don’t use GenAI to create or grade assignments or “fix” my own writing but I do occasionally put my assignments into ChatGPT to see what it produces, and that if I use GenAI in some other way related to our class I will let them know clearly and transparently. I also share a trick for bypassing Google AI overviews (put -ai before the search terms) since those are often not reliable.
I’m sure at least a few students are still using GenAI–sometimes I spot it and sometimes I don’t–but for the moment, I’m feeling better about teaching, and hopeful for our students’ futures, even while so much around us feels like it’s spiraling out of control.
GenAI and the Future of Work
Recently, I was talking with a student who wanted to major in computer science but became worried about later finding a job, so he decided on math instead but was not feeling very passionate about it, until he discovered the actuarial math major. When I asked what other things he might love to do if he could, I learned that his interests intersect technology and humanities: music production. He’s also a strong writer and has already taken multiple writing classes. We talked about being “practical” and also doing what you love, following your intuition, which can sometimes take a bit of searching. Other students have told me they’re worried about finding jobs in business or other fields because of companies’ increasing reliance on AI tech, or they more generally have concerns about what the future of work will look like once they graduate.
One of the “Academic Integrity in the Era of AI” panelists in computer science gave an example of using ChatGPT to get a sense of the job market for new graduates, since there’s so much news and information to parse through, and that it might offer better results for someone trying to keep up with what’s happening out there in real time. I wondered how reliable ChatGPT’s answers are in response, and I thought about creating assignments for students that ask them to research their potential fields, maybe even interviewing employers to get more perspectives on what their future work might look like, which could give them a better sense of agency by way of a tangible process of investigation and discovery.
I actually used to be more worried about my students’ professional futures, wondering if I should direct them away from “risky” majors so they might head toward more “practical” employment. That was before Covid, and before GenAI. To be clear, I still worry about them, but some of my concerns have shifted. During the Great Resignation, people quit jobs in droves, unable to justify literally risking their lives and mental health for work that “wouldn’t love them back.” Covid and the proliferation of AI tech have exponentially raised my awareness of the need for a strong humanities education and a serious shifting of the disparaging narratives. In a comp 106 class the other day I said, “I’m a proponent of following your intuition and doing what you love,” and I mean it more now than ever.
In recent semesters, particularly in first-year composition classes, I’ve shared examples that show how employers want workers with humanities educations–like science graduates who’ve taken philosophy and literature and history classes–and that those who major in liberal arts disciplines may in fact make similar pay over time compared to those in technical fields. We read about why “narrative medicine” is important for learning and practicing empathy and communication, and consider humanities in engineering. Individual stories differ, of course, but it seems clear that the arts, social sciences, history, philosophy, and literature are foundational for building insightful, critical, and creative workers across all fields. These human-centered skills may not look “efficient” or necessary from the outside, but they make for more well-rounded people communicating, empathizing, and solving problems in the world.
But students have to decide what it is they love and want to do, for themselves. They need to talk to advisors and trusted professors, do research into their potential fields, get experience through internships before they graduate. Whatever directions they head, no matter their majors and future careers, I hope they will see how their humanities education will only benefit them, how in fact the humanities are more important than ever.
We may not always know much more than our students, and sometimes we may even feel as confused, but we can help them to step back and use age-old strategies to hone critical and creative thinking skills and value the learning process, ultimately helping them to feel more resilient and empowered going forward.
GenAI at What Cost?
A topic left out of the panel conversation was climate, which to me is actually an important aspect of Academic Integrity. When I talk with my students about GenAI, I want them to decide not to use it in ways that will harm them academically or personally. And being honest with them about larger environmental and social consequences of “big data” gives them tools and resources to decide for themselves what kind of impact they want to have in the world. I don’t want them to “cheat” but I also don’t want to police or spend time trying to determine whether or not they’re doing their own work. I’ve found that having honest conversations about contemporary culture and society–through literary and historical texts or current news and research–in the context of GenAI and other technologies, engages students in critical processes of analysis and deep thinking about topics related to their real lives and futures.
Before GenAI became so widespread, many of us may not have thought much about data centers and the energy required for our increasing computing needs. But now it’s nearly impossible to ignore. Even if, as some argue, AI tech will eventually help us tackle climate change, we have to ask what happens in the meantime, before that (potentially) becomes reality?
This year, I’ve incorporated essays from Robin Wall Kimmerer’s Braiding Sweetgrass into my classes (which is the 2025-26 campus community read). In “Windigo Footprints,” she writes about traditional Windigo stories, told as warnings against insatiable greed and serving only oneself instead of considering the larger community. She connects that to contemporary economics and consumer culture, writing:
Ecological economists argue for reforms that would ground economics in ecological principles and the constraints of thermodynamics. They urge the embrace of the radical notion that we must sustain natural capital and ecosystem services if we are to maintain quality of life. But governments still cling to the neoclassical fallacy that human consumption has no consequences. We continue to embrace economic systems that prescribe infinite growth on a finite planet, as if somehow the universe had repealed the laws of thermodynamics on our behalf.
Tech companies are investing at a breakneck pace in all kinds of AI tech and the data centers needed to power it. They rely on marketing narratives to push acceptance and normalization while harnessing corporate profit motives that appear to sidestep short- and long-term climate goals. It’s an example of how economic tech bubbles benefit from narratives as cultural messaging that steer us to believe in things we might otherwise not. The stock market has been especially boosted, if not buoyed, by AI investment.
These tech companies also target students as an easy, immediate market and as potential long-term customers. The frantic speed at which AI is being integrated into K-12 education should give us pause. We may need more time to consider the larger context and consequences.
Process versus Product
I want my writing students to practice deep thinking (including analyzing cultural narratives and messaging), problem solving, being challenged to try (and sometimes fail) and to try again. I want them to learn that the process can (and maybe should) be a productive struggle, because often it’s in the struggle that we learn the most. Slow teaching, and slow learning as Anna Muller writes, are things that take time, that can’t be found via shortcuts.
In my classes I’ve incorporated new kinds of content to address living in the time of GenAI, and I’ve also cut back somewhat on the amount of reading in order to emphasize reading more actively through highlighting, annotating, and reflecting. Instead of using GenAI to summarize for them, I’ve seen students become more engaged readers, learning to synthesize other writers’ ideas with their own. And they gain confidence responding and bringing their perspectives into classroom conversations (or online discussion posts).
Reading is generally inseparable from developing strong writing skills, and writing is important for processing ideas and examples from the reading. And they are skills we shouldn’t simply delegate to technology without serious consideration of what may be lost. In “How Writing Leads to Thinking” Lynn Hunt explains that “writing is a magical and mysterious process that makes it possible to think differently.” Since Covid and the spread of GenAI in education, I’ve slowed down my teaching to have better conversations with students about writing as a means of thinking, through which we can make connections, learn about ourselves, and articulate ideas we may have had only vague notions of before beginning to write. In all of my classes we reflect on the real, human qualities intrinsic to writing and the arts, how narrative and storytelling are key to who we are, and that those can be used for good or insidious means.
Jonathan Alexander similarly argues for human versus GenAI writing in his essay, “Students’ Right to Write”:
Students’ experiences of writing…should be as rich and robust as possible. They carry those experiences not just into the workforce but into their personal and civic lives. The delight in language…is an experience all of our students should have—even when they experience it at times as difficult, even frustrating. Indeed, some of the surprising moments in our research have been when alumni have discussed how they really disliked writing that research paper at the time, but now miss the experience for what it taught them about writing—not just as a form of communication, but as a way of thinking.
Over many years of teaching, reflecting, and revising my pedagogy and practice, I’ve learned that holding students accountable for their own academic integrity shouldn’t be about policing but instead focused on learning, an idea reiterated by speakers on the Academic Integrity panel. Now that AI technologies seem to be infiltrating everything we do online, I believe more than ever in offering students opportunities for learning deeply, critically, creatively, and on their own terms, with all of the non-AI support and resources I am able to provide them. If it’s challenging and takes time and patience, then they’ll know they’re engaged in their own human, generative processes and may even come to understand more about themselves, and hopefully more about the world around them, because of it.
Additional Resources/Reading:
Refusing AI in Writing Studies website
Teaching AI Ethics (Leon Furze)
What Agency Means in the Era of Automation (Marc Watkins)
Marc Watkins substack
Embracing the Age of Agency (John Warner)
John Warner substack
What I Mean When I Say Critical AI Literacy (Maha Bali)
UM-Dearborn Community Read 2025-26: Braiding Sweetgrass by Robin Wall Kimmerer:
Connecting yesterday, today and tomorrow with sweetgrass
Teaching with Braiding Sweetgrass
Image by Yunuscan Zeybek from Pixabay

